Why are indigenous women in India lying on a mock funeral pyre?
National River Linking Project is one of the most ambitious environmental projects undertaken by India in recent periods. Its objective is to redistribute water from 'surplus' to deficit' river basins to contribute to the food security challenges. It will also inadvertently financially aid millions of farmers whose primary source of livelihood depends upon agriculture. But altering the natural flow of water comes with drastic environmental cost.
One of the major concerns raised by environmental experts are the textbook definition of 'surplus' and 'deficit' which they argue cannot be taken as constant throughout the year and across the years. The rationale of hydrological presumtion could prove otherwise. The rivers display seasonsal and year on year variational characteristics which could challenge the given assumption of 'surpluy' and 'deficit'. Other significant impacts are downstream flows and the natural habitat depending upon the existing ecosystem. At the receiving end of such a gigantic projects lies not just environemtnal costs but also human costs - the primary among which is displacement of local communities, altering the habitat of indigenous communities and victims of natural calamities like flooding owing to the change in river course.
As the government goes ahead with this proposed project, communities have expressed their dissatisfaction. The first phase of the project connects Madhya Pradesh's Ken River to Uttar Pradesh's Betwa River.
The women members have been staging a unique way of protest where they have been lying down on a mock funeral pyre with mud smeared on their faces. They are calling it as 'Chita Andolon' (pyre protest) or 'Chita Satyagraha' (peaceful protest over funeral pyre) demanding justice or death.
The indigenous communities wants to highlight the organic connection between the natural habitat and the community members and lying on the funeral pyre indicates their death when this organic relation is fractured. They also want to highlight the impact that flooding of their area has caused since the project was initiated. The issue, naturally, has eluded the mainstream media and has received scant reporting by the news channel. The construction of the Daudhan Dam as part of this phase will submerge close to 9000 hectares of land and that includes zones insider the Panna Tiger Reserve and te surrounding villages.

Indigenous women lying over mock funeral pyre. Source: Times of India
Compensation to the affacted families was raised from INR 500,000 to 1.25 million per hectare. Although dissatisfaction over the amount persists among some families. The project has its advantgaes considering the dependence on farming by a substantial portion of the rural population and the rising concerns over food security. Although the affected families (in this case the indigenous population) will not directly benefit from the project. However, challenges emanating from altering the natural cource of a river requires thorough and effective evaluation. The other concern is the environmental compensation owing to the large scale damages to the ecosystem will also need clear explanation. The protest at the start of the project could trigger other communities to be cautious of their situation once the project reaches their respective habitat. At the moment there appears to be a communication gap among the multiple stakeholders which could only deepen the misunderstandings instead of allaying their fears.
Sources:





Comments